Arrrr, me hearties! What think ye of a venture to raise a gigantic hoard of sunken treasure?

The story begins with the last voyage of RMS Republic. This was a luxurious passenger steamship of the White Star Line, which sailed between Europe and America.

Wikipedia

Republic was a large vessel (15,000 tons displacement) for her day, and was known as the “Millionaires’ Ship” for the number of wealthy Americans who sailed back and forth on her. A number of such magnates were aboard on her last voyage. In January, 1909 Republic left New York City with  passengers and crew, bound for Gibraltar and Mediterranean ports. In thick fog off the island of Nantucket, Republic was rammed amidships by the Italian liner Florida. Florida’s bow was crumpled back, but she stayed afloat. The damage to Republic was fatal. The engine rooms flooded, the ship began to list, and it was clear that the passengers needed to be evacuated.

Using the new-fangled Marconi “wireless” apparatus, a CQD distress signal was broadcast by radio operator Jack Binns. This was the first wireless transmission that resulted in a major life-saving marine rescue. (Binns had to scramble and improvise to get this done, since his apparatus had been damaged and the ship’s power was lost as a result of the collision, so he was a technology nerd turned hero, duly lauded by a ticker-tape parade). It was hard for other ships to locate Republic in the fog, but eventually nearly all the passengers and crew from Republic and from the damaged Florida were safely transferred to other ships.

As was the custom of the time, she did not carry enough lifeboats to hold all the passengers, but only enough to ferry them to some other ship; it was assumed that on the busy Atlantic route there would always be other large ships around.  (That scheme played out well with the Republic, but when sister White Star liner Titanic sank four years later, the dearth of lifeboats helped doom some 1,500 people to a watery grave.) Despite efforts to save her, Republic went down stern-first on January 24. She was the largest ship ever to sink at the time.  There were reports at the time that she was carrying some $3 million (1909 dollars) of gold, which went down with the ship. That would translate to hundreds of millions of dollars today for that gold.

But wait, there’s more, maybe much more. Enter a modern-day pirate, Martin Bayerle:

Vineyard Gazette

Bayerle looks like a pirate, sporting a genuine eyepatch covering an eye lost in an explosives accident. He killed a man who was fooling around with his wife, which seems like a piratical thing to do, and he is after a ship’s gold.   His salvage enterprise is even formally described in legal court papers as “modern day pirates”. 

His company, Martha’s Vineyard Scuba Headquarters, Inc. (“MVSHQ”), acquired salvage rights to the wreck of the Republic. In 2013 he published a book, The Tsar’s Treasure, detailing his thesis that Republic carried far more gold than was publicly acknowledged. He notes that there was no formal inquiry regarding the sinking of Republic, which was highly unusual and is suggestive of a cover-up. Cover-up of what?

Well, Europe at the time was a tinder box of potential conflict, which did in fact erupt five years later in World War I.  Czarist Russia was a key part of the European military equation. Britain was counting on Russia to help contain the emerging militaristic Germany. Russia had incurred huge debts in its disastrous war with Japan in 1905. Russia was about to issue a new round of bonds in 1909, to roll over its debt from 1905. It was critical that that bond issuance would go forward.

Bayerle believes that a large amount of gold was stashed in the hold of the Republic, destined for European banks, to support the Russian bonds of 1909. The revelation that that gold was lost would have jeopardized this crucial financial transaction, perhaps leading to Russia’s collapse, which is something Britain could not afford. Hence, the cover-up. Bayerle estimates that the value of this trove is up to $10 billion in today’s money. Shiver me timbers!

This geopolitical speculation, together with stories of failed previous salvage attempts on Republic, all make for a rollicking yarn. Is it for real? Nobody knows, but Bayerle is offering investors a chance at a slice of the booty. If you are inclined to “Dare to dream the impossible” (per the website), you have the opportunity to invest in his Lords of Treasure enterprise as they make a dive on the site this summer.

I don’t happen to have that much risk appetite, but it should be an interesting story to follow.

UPDATE

According to the June 2025 Lords of Fortune Newletter, salvage operations originally slated for 2025 are being put off till 2026, as funding is still being developed. We note the technical challenge of picking through hundreds of tons of steel plate and girders, deep underwater, in search of a smallish volume of gold. On the other hand, Capt. Bayerle’s recent researches suggest the gold trove may be even larger than earlier estimated, up to some $30 billion. So high risk meets high reward here. It seems ironic that VC’s will throw say $300 million into dubious tech unicorns or the latest crap-coin, but eschew a pretty sure bet of at least breaking even here (if only the lowest estimates of the Republic gold pan out) with a good shot at 10X-ing their investment. We will stay tuned.