Place-Based Subsidies Aren’t Great Job Creators

That turned out to be the commonality among the four papers I discussed at the Association for Public Policy Analysis and Management last weekend:

In “Subsidizing Data Centers”, Vijay Prakash found that US states subsidizing data centers saw no significant difference in unemployment (or electric prices) compared to those that didn’t.

2. In “Spillover Effects of Million Dollar Projects on Wage Distribution and Skill Demand“, Alaa Abdelfattah (with Layla O’Kane) found that big new business projects (mean investment $333 million, mean subsidy $130 million) led to no increase in total job postings in the counties that ‘won’ the project relative to counties that were reportedly the ‘runner-up’.

3. Of course, if you spend enough money, it is possible to bring jobs to an area. In “Where the CHIPS Fall: Local Labor Market Impacts of Semiconductor Mega-Investments in Maricopa County, Arizona“, Pinghui Wu (with Annie Liu) found that the billions spent on subsidies did bring jobs to Arizona- but at a cost of $136,000 to $190,000 per job-year.

4. Will the jobs remain once the subsidies are gone? They mostly didn’t in Puerto Rico. In “Corporate Tax Incentives Retraction: Evidence from Puerto Rico”, Dayanara M. Diaz Vargas found that the end of Section 936 tax credits in 2006 led to a 28% decline in manufacturing employment.

The results reminded me of subsidies for sports stadiums, which always promise to bring jobs and economic activity but rarely deliver:

Welcome Back, Divided Government

Last week I predicted:

the midterm wipeout is coming.

I predicted a ‘moderate red wave’ here in 2022. I predict a blue wave for 2026 that is bigger than the red wave of 2022, though not a ‘mega tsunami‘

That post looks good now with the exception of those last five words- it was in fact a blue ‘mega tsunami’ by Kalshi’s definition (Democrats hold 240+ House and 54+ Senate seats).

Polling from the WSJ backs up my assessment that this was mainly about the economy and prices:

This comes after a longtime WSJ editorial writer hoped for a big Republican loss, something I’ve never seen from the WSJ before. But if they speak for the markets, it makes sense- US stocks opened up 2% the day after the election.

Crypto and gold prices are also up, an odd combination. Oil prices are down, perhaps seeing an end to the Iran war as more likely. Polymarket shows the odds of a US invasion of Iran this year down 5%. John Ossoff and Ron Desantis saw their odds of becoming President in 2028 rise at the expense of JD Vance and Gavin Newsom.

What will we see change on economic policy? Congress may lower tariffs and take back some of the tariff power they have long delegated to presidents. The Federal Reserve board will feel more free to raise interest rates if they think it is warranted. Many state-level results mean data centers will get harder to build, which will hurt the ‘picks and shovels’ companies literally building them but not necessarily the frontier labs who won’t be able to spend as much on racing ahead. NVDA and Micron stock is down while Google, Meta, Anthropic and OpenAI are up.

But the fact that President Trump still has veto power will limit how many big changes we’ll see over the next two years for anything that would require a new bill. Welcome back to divided government, to gridlock, and to checks and balances.

Midterms: It’s The Economy

This is my last post before the midterms Tuesday. What will they bring?

Midterm elections are usually bad for the President’s party:

I don’t think this year will be an exception to the rule. I see many indicators pointing in the same direction.

The largest US prediction market Kalshi currently gives Democrats a 91% chance to take the House and a 66% chance to take the Senate. The international Polymarket and play-money Manifold currently give slightly higher chances, 93/67 and 94/69. Forecaster Nate Silver is higher still at 95/76.

The best odds I’m seeing for Republicans among the models I have followed for years is Ray Fair giving Dems only a 60% chance to take the House (he doesn’t forecast the Senate). In Fair’s model, the economy is working in favor of Republicans; inflation is a negative for them but economic growth is a stronger positive (including the 3.4% Q3 GDP estimate just released today).

In practice though I think economic issues are working in favor of Democrats. The economy is good in many ways, like 4.2% unemployment- but most people aren’t happy about it. Consumer sentiment is at record lows. Economic growth is solid but largely driven by the AI boom, which gives people plenty to be nervous about. Inflation is only a bit high (3.4% vs a 2% target) but easy to tie to administration policies like tariffs, war, and pressuring the Fed to lower interest rates. Ad spending indicates that politicians on both sides think tariffs have gone from a minor issue that voters have mixed feelings about to a major issue that voters don’t like:

Gas prices have long been especially salient, and are currently high because of the Iran war. I said here in March:

if the US administration wants to avoid a midterm wipeout driven by high gas prices, I see only 3 options:

  1. Get lucky and see the Iranian regime fall quickly
  2. Negotiate an end to the war quickly (which might itself be unpopular if they can’t get a good deal) or just declare victory and go home (but its not clear whether Iran would re-open the strait now just because the US stopped bombing)
  3. Restrict Exports

But they took none of those three options, and now it seems the midterm wipeout is coming.

I predicted a ‘moderate red wave’ here in 2022. I predict a blue wave for 2026 that is bigger than the red wave of 2022, though not a ‘mega tsunami‘. The main things Republicans have going for them are the Senate map (Dems need to win in multiple 2024 red states to win) and the possibility that angry anti-incumbent voters will take down some Dems too.

A Simple Way States Can Reduce Healthcare Spending

Repeal Certificate of Need requirements, assuming you are one of the ~35 states that have them.

That’s what I find in a paper with Shishir Shakya just published in Health Economics.

Certificate of Need laws require healthcare providers to obtain government approval before building new facilities or expanding services. The original intent of the laws was that less building would mean less spending, but critics worry that it means less competition and higher prices leading to higher spending. Our paper finds that the critics are right, as states repealing their Certificate of Need laws see their healthcare spending fall relative to those that maintain them.

Longtime readers may recall that back in 2022 I posted about another paper of mine with a similar result, and even that wasn’t the first word on the subject. So what’s new in this paper? Besides newer data, we measure health spending as a percentage of the state economy rather than in raw dollars, to try to account for how CON changes the true burden of healthcare spending. We also use newer regression techniques that are probably more accurate but definitely help make prettier graphs.

Here’s what we found happening to health spending when states repeal Certificate of Need:

Full published paper is here, ungated working paper version here.

Health Insurance Benefit Mandates and Premiums

The Center for Modern Health just released a report “Paring Down Coverage Mandates To Reduce Health Insurance Premiums“. It builds on one of my papers to estimate how much states could drive down insurance premiums by reducing the number of things health insurers are required to cover:

Estimated savings for Family Plans (Table 2 of CMH Report)

It’s nice to see that someone in the health policy world remembers that health insurance benefit mandates exist and can be a significant cost driver. I’m also glad to see that someone still cares about my 2014 paper (the first one I ever got accepted at a journal), though I wish there were more up to date estimates available for them to cite.

Why has no one developed more recent estimates? Partly for data reasons- the organizations that had been putting out counts of mandates by state each year (the Council for Affordable Health Insurance & Blue Cross Blue Shield Association) stopped doing so. Partly because of the ACA, which changed how mandates worked in complex ways.

That said, there there seems to be some more recent data from 2017 that could be used for a slight update, and this post and my ideas page detail the many things we still don’t know about how mandates operated prior to 2014:

State Health Insurance Mandates: Most of my early work was on these laws, but many questions remain unanswered. States have passed over a hundred different types of mandated benefits, but the vast majority have zero papers focused on them. Many likely effects of the laws have also never been studied for any mandate or combination of mandates. Do they actually reduce uncompensated hospital care, as Summers (1989) predicts? Do mandates cause higher deductibles and copays, less coverage of non-mandated care, or narrower networks? How do mandates affect the income and employment of relevant providers? Can mandates be used as an instrument to determine the effectiveness of a treatment? How does all this change in light of the ACA? On the identification side, redoing older papers using a dataset like MEPS-IC where self-insured firms can be used as a control would be a major advance.

Economic Freedom Is Enough

Adam Smith kicked off modern economics by asking what causes nations to become wealthy. We’ve spent centuries improving our answers to the question and we still have lots to learn, but I think Smith’s original answer holds up remarkably well:

Little else is requisite to carry a state to the highest degree of opulence from the lowest barbarism, but peace, easy taxes, and a tolerable administration of justice; all the rest being brought about by the natural course of things. All governments which thwart this natural course, which force things into another channel, or which endeavour to arrest the progress of society at a particular point, are unnatural, and to support themselves are obliged to be oppressive and tyrannical

I was reminded of this by the latest Economic Freedom of the World report just released:

The overall correlation of GDP per capital and economic freedom is strong, but I find the extremes even more striking. Economic freedom is necessary for wealth: every country with a GDP per capita above $50,000 has above-average economic freedom (getting even close without high economic freedom requires having lots of oil). Economic freedom is sufficient: every country with an economic freedom rating over 8 has a GDP per capita over $50,000.

I periodically see someone claim that a country “did everything right” in terms of policy but still wound up poor, usually implying that the country is doomed by their geography or genes, or arguing that “neoliberal policy” failed. Whenever I check in on these countries, I inevitably find them to be far from “doing everything right”, with economic freedom scores typically far below 8.

It’s true that these are “just correlations” and that economic freedom alone isn’t a perfect predictor. It’s worth looking into the outliers and wondering- if a country is above the trend line without oil wealth (like China), what else are they doing right? If a country is well below the overall trend line (like Guatemala), does it mean they are have something else working against them to counteract the benefits of economic freedom? Or does it mean they are about to turn the corner and see high economic growth?

Overall though I don’t think it’s a big oversimplification to say that Adam Smith was right, and economic freedom is enough to bring prosperity. If you’re looking for economic growth, start with Smith’s peace, easy taxes, and tolerable administration of justice, or the Economic Freedom of the World’s small government, strong property rights and legal system, sound money, and freedom to trade at home and abroad.

Music Spending Is Smaller Share Of A Bigger Pie

We noted that “People Are Paying For Music Again” in 2024, showing that streaming was partly making up for the drop in sales of physical recordings, while live music sales were setting record highs. Thus,

When you combine live and recorded sales, total spending on music has now passed the 1999 peak; this is the biggest the market for music has ever been.

But I didn’t have a chart showing the music market as a whole. I meant to make on for a followup post, but still hadn’t got around to it when I saw this from Joey Politano’s Apricitas Substack:

He uses BEA data instead of the music industry sources I was using, which means a wider range of years is available, and the colors tell the story nicely. This chart still shows a late ’90s peak because it is measuring music as a percentage of all consumer spending; but total real consumer spending is way up since the ’90s, so the real dollar peak of money flowing to the music industry is today. Here’s my version of the chart using real dollars:

This chart tells a more optimistic story. But it’s worth reading the entirety of Politano’s post, which suggests that AI is already significantly reducing overall employment in the arts. He also notes that money moving from recorded to live music has changed which artists are winning. I’ve noted something of a ‘rich get richer’ phenomenon, with ticket prices for top artists shooting higher while it becomes harder for regular musicians to stay full time.

My semi-serious solution is to bring back hipsters. Make it once again cooler to spend $20 each weekend on an obscure band’s show or vinyl than to spend $1000 on a VIP ticket to a Taylor Swift-level show once a year. Hipsters might be annoying, but the hipster music strategy is an efficient way to support more people putting in the time to make music- and I think that would be a good thing in a field where talent is fairly widely distributed. The difference between full-time musicians and semi-pros who do a few gigs a year (or the best amateurs) is often not musical talent but luck, connections, and the willingness and ability to push through early years with little income. We’re a richer society than we were in 1999 and we can afford to support more people giving music a real try.

Introducing the Certificate of Need Panel Database

Certificate of Need (CON) laws require healthcare providers to obtain state approval before opening new facilities, expanding existing facilities, or introducing certain healthcare services or equipment. We’ve covered them frequently here, and I’ve written several papers on them.

But my research evaluating the effects of CON on healthcare facilities, spending, and outcomes (along with everyone else’s) always had the drawback that we relied on fairly crude measures of CON- often just a binary measure of whether a state had any CON requirements at all. The problem with this is that different states have wildly different approaches to CON- some states like Vermont require CON for as many as 27 separate types of health facilities, services, or equipment, including major ones like hospitals, while other states like Ohio require CON for only a single type (nursing homes). Previous attempts to catalog this variation tended to produce single-year snapshots (e.g. Institute for Justice, Cicero, Mercatus, NCSL). These are helpful for policymakers wanting to see how their state compares to others, but not so useful to researchers trying to measure the effects of CON, who would typically prefer many years of historical data.

The dataset us CON researchers have always wanted is now here!

It tracks 31 different types of healthcare facilities, services, and equipment that are sometimes regulated by CON, showing which ones required a CON in each state in every year back to 1990 (going even further back for some states). This means our national panel has more than 55,000 data points.

Number of Certificate of Need Requirements Per State, 2025

I’ve spent the last 2+ years working on this with a large team of coauthors (Sriparna Ghosh, Conor Norris, and Justin Leventhal) and research assistants, with support from Providence College and the Knee Regulatory Research Center at WVU. It involved reading decades of old state statutes on HeinOnline and Westlaw. We’ve released a paper, Certificate of Need: A New Comprehensive Panel, explaining the dataset in more detail and sharing ideas for how researchers could use it.

Change In Certificate of Need Requirements Per State, 1990 to 2025
Change In Number of States Requiring Each Type of CON From 1990 to 2025

The dataset is public and free for everyone to use- we just ask that people cite us (though feel free to ask any of the dataset’s creators if you do want us as coauthors on your paper using the data). I’d love to hear your ideas for how you might use it, or how we can improve it- this is Version 1.0 but we plan to maintain and improve it going forward so that it can become the standard for the field.

The World Keeps Spinning Faster

So many things are happening that it’s hard to decide which to write about. So I’ll briefly cover several that would each deserve a full post on a normal week:

1. The Fed voted unanimously to raise rates to 4%, showing that the Warsh Fed still has some independence from the President.

2. The 10-year Treasury bond hit 5%. The CBO’s long-term budget forecasts assume 4% rates for the 10-year, and looked unpleasant even with that rosy assumption. The UK dumped Prime Minister Liz Truss over their 10-year hitting 4.5%.

3. Jacob Coxon resigned from Anthropic over AI safety concerns and set off a surprisingly large firestorm over it.

4. The Trump administration reacted by insisting we move forward with AI, with the Department of War blaming Effective Altruists for trying to slow it down:

I suspect this could lead many people to get into Effective Altruism by promoting it from ‘weird thing for nerds‘ to ‘something you can do to oppose Trump’. If that interests you, this is a good place to start.

5. EA hero Michael Kremer (whose work inspired many donations to deworming) was just appointed Chief Economist of the World Bank.

6. But AI progress keeps rolling. Quantum theorist Scott Aaronson declares the Singularity is here:

I recoil from the neverending shell game where you say “oh sure, of course AI can now [escape from its sandbox / solve Millennium Problems / whichever dramatic thing it most recently did], no one ever denied that [I did deny it], wake me up when AI does [thing AI hasn’t yet done but is going to do next year], that’s when I’ll reevaluate my whole worldview [no I won’t].” Where no matter how fast the rollercoaster accelerates, even after your whole familiar world has vanished behind you, you’re still inventing reasons why it doesn’t count.

My position on AI is merely the conservative, skeptical position of 2006, updated with intellectual honesty for the reality of late 2026. And that position, if you need me to spell it out, is as follows:

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

It seems to me that the Singularity has already started; it’s just wildly unevenly distributed.

I’m honestly surprised we have yet to see an upsurge of millenarianism. Y2K concerns came and went 2000 years after Jesus’ birth. But see how much people worry about AI now, and realize it will only get more powerful as we approach 2000 years after his death- 2033, or if you trust the revisionists, 2030.

New Health Freedom Index

The Center for Modern Health and the Knee Regulatory Research Center just released an index of how free residents in each state are to provide and pursue health care as they see fit. Their summary map looks like this:

The index was created by averaging measures of freedom in 54 separate categories, summarized into the 5 broad areas of Professional, Institutional, Patient, Payment, and Delivery Freedom. A report with maps for each of the 54 underlying measures is here, and a spreadsheet with all the data is here.

This project represents a major effort on an important issue, but I have to say my favorite part is just how unusual the final map of the overall ranking looks. I’ve created many maps of the states based on data and seen many more, but almost all of them (no matter the underlying variable they represent) end up falling into a handful of looks. They are either secretly maps of population density, or North vs South, or East vs West, or the South + Appalachia (high poverty, low health and education, et c). But the Health Freedom Index groups states in a way I’ve never seen before, putting Maine and New Hampshire with Mountain West states as the most free, while South Carolina and Louisiana join California and much of the Northeast among the least free.

Some of the Index’s creators will be presenting it online on September 18th.

Note: I’m affiliated with the Knee Regulatory Research Center at WVU, but I wasn’t directly involved with this project. I’m working on a different data project with Knee I hope to discuss here soon.