Chair Report

In the summer of 2025, I was assigned to be Chair of my school’s Economics Department. I announced it here and listed some things that I wanted to achieve. Now it’s near the end of the Fall 2026 semester and I want to provide a progress report. Below is a brief list of what I wanted to do with some details and at the bottom are some additions. As with any goals, we have to be careful that the goal corresponds to our desired outcomes. With that loose joint in mind, here we go!

Goals:

  • Host guest speakers

Success: We hosted doctors Art Laffer, Craig Gunderson, Joy Buchanan, and Marc Fusaro to talk about economic policy, food stamps, fast fashion, AI in the classroom, and access to liquidity among lower-income households. Understandably, the lecture with Art Laffer was the biggest and got us a lot of exposure outside of the school. We have more to come in the spring. Does this improve enrollment and enthusiasm for Economics? It really is hard to say. But I suspect that it helps more than it hurts.

  • Host faculty lectures

All of our three full-time faculty, and even our adjuncts, have hosted public events. These include lectures on usury, banking crisis contagion, deaf human capital, and coffee consumption. These had a mix of attendance. I think these are nice in that they require less admin to prepare, even though they are time-consuming for the lecturer. But these also communicate to the students that we’re a serious place. I once had a student who was surprised that we conduct research and publish. Students come from a variety of backgrounds with a variety of preconceptions, and by hosting our own events, we can show them that we’re not just glorified instructors.

  • A dedicated study room for majors

We have a weekly reserved classroom for Economics majors to use as a dedicated study space. It’s only used sporadically.

  • Econ social events

Last year we hosted an “Econ Social” that included students and friends of the department. The plan was for alumni to attend, but the university cancelled its alumni weekend. So, it was only ‘ok’. This year, we’re providing more notice, we know who we can depend on, and it will probably be better. I want to host a more chill ‘senior night’. We’ll see how it goes.

  • Emails of gratitude

I still send a sizeable proportion of my students an email of gratitude. I still think it matters. I suggest it also to my colleagues. But I think that they think that it’s not their style. C’est la vie.

  • More cross-listed electives

This has been moderately successful. We’ve had a cross-listed History course and Politics course for a long time. We’ve added Western Economic History to the Political Economy major, which is run by Politics, and we’re exploring whether it is sensible to make Micro/Macro economics w/Calculus or Game Theory count as applied Math classes. The big impact would be to offer a class in Communications or Psychology. But we don’t have adequate specialization for that and those students tend to be quantitatively weaker.

  • Economics club

The Economics club is now a thing! I’m not the faculty adviser, but they’ve promoted attendance at a few of our events already, including a panel that they requested titled “Will AI Take Our Jobs?”. So, it’s actually functioning. Next year they’ll qualify for funding if they can successfully pass the torch.

  • Internships

I didn’t mention this in the main post last time, but I’ve been working to emphasize internships so that students graduate with experience or with their foot already in the door somewhere. What do I actually do? Every August, I persistently email my students until they complete a summer activity survey. Then, I clean up the data and give it back to them. They can see important details about where their peers interned and also see advice. This makes finding a relevant internship much easier. Below is a factsheet that I plan to share with all majors, alumni, and friends of the department.

Anthropic Ascends Throne

It’s always nice to see a private company you invested in early get its big day on the front page of the Wall Street Journal:

Unfortunately for my bank account, the company I’m talking about isn’t the one that just IPO’d at over a trillion dollar valuation to become the ~12th-most valuable company in the world, Anthropic. It is the maker of the bathrooms featured at the bottom-right of the page, Throne:

I Tried New York City’s New High-Tech Public Bathrooms—and Saw the Future

Throne makes public bathrooms nicer partly through how they are built, but partly through a phone-based rating and entry system:

getting in requires a little effort. You can scan a QR code to send the company a text, download an app or, for the phoneless, get an entry card from the city or local businesses.

Entry is free, but like all social contracts, there is a price.

If you have the Throne app on your phone, it will ask you to rate the bathroom as soon as you walk in, for cleanliness and smell. That’s how the company knows how the previous visitor treated (or mistreated) the space. If you left the place in a dire state, you’ll get a warning. Keep it up and your account—linked to your phone, not your person—will be banned.

Because people know they will be rated, most appear to treat these bathrooms better than other public facilities. Like many “Why can’t we have nice things?” scenarios, the biggest problems come from a small fraction of users…..

The city is paying Throne $225,000 per bathroom for their two-year residence, including all maintenance and cleaning. Previous restrooms cost the city $3 million apiece and were, as many residents reported, borderline unusable.

Throne is a good company and I’m glad I invested, though of course investing in Anthropic in 2023 would have returned much better. Why didn’t I invest in Anthropic before today? It’s not that I didn’t believe in their stock- it’s that I couldn’t buy any. In addition to the usual private-company limitation to accredited investors, Anthropic only ever sold stock directly to a small number of selected investors, and tried to legally restrict the ability of their equity-holders to sell on the secondary market.

Until today, the closest almost anyone could get to Anthropic stock was to buy a piece of a different company or fund, like Zoom or DXYZ, that happened to hold some Anthropic shares. Throne, by contrast, opened their doors wide to even non-accredited investors through equity crowdfunding. Perhaps someday they will go public and be my next private exit.

But today, congrats to Anthropic and their early investors. I hope you find good things to do with the money, and that your company doesn’t destroy the world.

Spending on Food Delivery is Highly Concentrated Among a Small Number of Households

A recent article at Business Insider on food delivery spending has several quotes from me. It’s a good article, but you all know that I love charts to go along with text, so here are a few accompanying charts.

The BI reporter contacted me because of a few tweets I wrote about spending on food delivery, the first was that the median household in all age groups spends $0 on food delivery services. In fact, you have to go well above the median household to find any reported spending on food services, since 84 percent report no food delivery spending in the Fed’s Survey of Consumer Finances.

Figure 1

The data comes from the Fed’s Survey of Consumer Finances, which is primarily designed to measure wealth data for households, but also gives us some interesting data on a few other areas of consumer finances, including some spending variables. Because the survey doesn’t give us a full accounting of consumer spending, we should take it as suggestive rather than definitive, but more comprehensive consumer spending surveys such as the one from BLS don’t separate out food delivery spending (even in the publicly available microdata).

But even that 84 percent figure understates just how concentrated food delivery spending is among a small share of households: just 3 percent of households account for about half of all food delivery spending, and the top 1% of spenders (not necessarily the richest 1%, just the top 1% in this category) account for around 28 percent of food delivery spending. Median food delivery spending for the top 1% of spenders is $7,800 per year, or $150 every week. That’s a lot of pizzas. The median spending for those with any food spending (the top 16%) was $1,800 in 2025.

Figure 2

Edward O. Thorp, The Math Professor Who Beat Vegas, Then Wall Street

Edward O. Thorp grew up in Depression-era California, a tinkering kid who cooked up homemade nitroglycerin with a chemistry set. (That gets my respect, since as a kid I only made it to manufacturing old-fashioned black gunpowder). He became a math professor, worked out how to count cards at blackjack, and published Beat the Dealer in 1962.

He didn’t just theorize. He took a $10,000 bankroll from a gambler and hit Vegas in 1961, and started making big winnings at blackjack. Casinos soon realized something was up. Nevada casinos are private businesses and can simply ask a winning player to leave, so he was often “backed off” rather than formally blacklisted. To keep playing, Thorp used disguises, including wigs, glasses, and a fake beard. Based on his achievements, Thorp was an inaugural member of the Blackjack Hall of Fame.* (As a countermeasure to his methods, casinos now shuffle long before the end of the deck is reached in blackjack.) Thorp also teamed up with information-theory legend Claude Shannon to build what’s often called the first wearable computer, a cigarette-pack-sized gadget to beat roulette.

Wall Street, it turned out, was just a bigger casino. Thorp’s trading came down to a simple idea: find things that are priced wrong relative to each other, and let math tell you how much to bet. With Sheen Kassouf, he spotted that warrants (long-dated options issued by companies) were often mispriced against the underlying stock. They bought the cheap one, shorted the expensive one, and adjusted the ratio as prices moved so the position stayed balanced. This is what we now call delta hedging. Thorp also worked out an options pricing formula on his own, years before Black and Scholes published theirs in 1973, and used it quietly to trade. In the 1980s his team moved into statistical arbitrage, using computers to hunt for small, repeatable mispricings across lots of stocks at once. Throughout, he used the Kelly criterion to size positions, so no single bet could sink the fund.

His fund, Princeton Newport Partners, ran from 1969 to 1988 and returned roughly 19% (!!) a year after fees, with no losing calendar years and low volatility. That is a stunning record, both on returns and drawdowns (high Sharpe ratio), considering it spanned the 1973-74 bear market and the 1987 crash. His later fund, Ridgeline Partners, reportedly did similarly well. He is often cited as one of the most successful (G.O.A.T.) traders ever, and a pioneer in quant investing. Using faster computers and bigger datasets, a modern quant shop is like Thorp on steroids: many small hedged bets, following models rather than hunches, and strict risk control. Convertible arbitrage, stat arb, and market-neutral investing all trace back to people like Thorp

Thriving in Bear Markets

A traditional long-only investor needs stocks to go up. When the market tanks, they just suffer. Thorp’s approach didn’t care much about market direction. If you’re long the underpriced thing and short the overpriced thing, you’re betting on the gap closing, not on the market rising. Panic can even help, since mispricings get bigger when everyone’s scared. As an amateur connoisseur of uncorrelated assets, I find this intriguing. (See this earlier post on market-neutral funds which are available to retail investors).

This is not so easy to do. First, edges can fade: once everyone copies your math, the free lunch shrinks and trades get overcrowded. Also, the spreads per trade are small, which leads traders to leverage up, which can destroy you in a day if markets go against you. A big part of Thorp’s success was sizing bets carefully and staying alive long enough for the edge to compound.

* The “Blackjack Hall of Fame” is housed at Barona Resort & Casino near San Diego. The Barona Casino awards to each inductee a permanent lifetime complimentary full room, food, and beverage, in exchange for each member’s agreement never to play on Barona’s tables.

What I’ve been listening to

It’s all economics if you think about it…anyway, here’s some bands I’ve been listening to:

  1. Alvilda has become my go to “vibe while I do stuff” band. No I don’t speak french, yet somehow I still know they rule. Music is funny that way.

2. Twisted Teens. This band just has it.

3. Tee Vee Repairmann answer the question “Does the world need a time machine to get another album out of The Nerves?” The answer is yes.

And hey, The Chats have a new single out, so let’s close with that because they remain undefeated.

Grok on the Microsoft Outlook failure

Joy Buchanan prompt: “Was the internet originally designed with many nodes to make it more secure and hard to take down? How did so many of us become so vulnerable to a failure like the one that took down Outlook email on 11/12/26?”

Grok response: Yes, the internet’s foundational architecture was deliberately designed for resilience and to avoid single points of failure. (https://www.darpa.mil/news/features/arpanet)

In the early 1960s, RAND researcher Paul Baran developed the concept of distributed (as opposed to centralized or hierarchical) communications networks. His goal was a system that could keep functioning even if many nodes and links were destroyed—specifically in the context of a nuclear attack that might wipe out key telephone switching centers. Messages would be broken into small “message blocks” (later called packets) that could take dynamic, alternate routes through a mesh of interconnected nodes and reassemble at the destination. Donald Davies independently developed similar packet-switching ideas in the UK. These concepts strongly influenced ARPANET (the precursor to the internet), which launched in 1969 with four nodes (UCLA, Stanford Research Institute, UC Santa Barbara, and University of Utah) using Interface Message Processors connected by leased lines in a redundant topology. Packet switching and dynamic routing meant that failure of individual links or nodes would not necessarily take down the whole network—packets simply found other paths.

The core internet still reflects this: it is a network of networks with many autonomous systems, diverse routing paths, and no single central control point that can easily take everything offline.

Why the November 12, 2026 Outlook/Microsoft 365 Outage Hit So Many People

The outage that began around midday ET on November 12, 2026 (and continued into November 13) was not a failure of the internet’s backbone. It was a large-scale outage of Microsoft’s cloud-hosted Microsoft 365 services, primarily centered on Exchange Online (the backend for Outlook email). Microsoft confirmed it was a technical issue with no evidence of malicious activity or a cyberattack.

  • A significant number of servers failed automated health checks and dropped out of service.
  • This shifted load onto the remaining infrastructure, which then struggled (including a process responsible for establishing secure connections becoming overwhelmed).
  • The trigger was traced to an issue introduced during an earlier network capacity upgrade that surfaced after a subsequent network configuration change. Microsoft reverted relevant changes, restarted and stabilized servers, and gradually restored service while validating stability. Full post-incident details were promised later. nbcchicago.com

The vulnerability comes from extreme centralization of services on top of a resilient network. Most people and organizations no longer run their own email servers, file storage, or collaboration tools. They rely on a handful of hyperscale providers (Microsoft, Google, Amazon, etc.) for integrated, convenient, feature-rich cloud platforms. When something goes wrong in one provider’s large shared infrastructure—whether a configuration change, cascading health-check failures, capacity issues, or software problems—millions of users are affected simultaneously. The underlying internet can still route packets fine; the problem is that the application and data are concentrated behind a single company’s systems and operational processes. This concentration is driven by economics, convenience, integration (email + calendars + Teams + storage + AI all in one), scale efficiencies, and the difficulty of running high-availability services yourself.

Joy Buchanan prompt: “Is these like those medieval princes who could have used their surplus resources to keep a small personal army on hand but instead spent their money on fancy clothes and lost their power?”

Grok response: Medieval princes (or lords) often did face a classic principal-agent / security dilemma: surplus resources could have bought loyal retainers, fortifications, or a standing force that preserved independence. Many instead spent on display, court life, imported luxuries, or alliances that left them dependent on others when a real threat arrived. Loss of coercive capacity or local autonomy followed.

Today’s version with email and productivity services is structurally similar in one important way: organizations and users have (or had) the technical option to keep more control — running their own mail servers, hybrid setups, multiple providers, or more decentralized tools — but most have chosen the convenience, integration, and lower immediate cost of a few hyperscale platforms.

[I will omit the part where Grok told me how strong and helpful my analogy is.]

Where it differs

  • Not mostly “fancy clothes.” Cloud services deliver genuine, ongoing value — higher typical uptime than most self-hosted setups, better security patching at scale for many threat models, collaboration features that small or mid-size teams cannot easily replicate, and cost advantages from massive economies of scale. The choice is often rational under normal conditions, not pure display.
  • Feasibility and expertise barriers: Running reliable, secure, high-availability email at any real scale is hard. Spam, phishing, compliance (especially regulated industries), and deliverability problems are constant. Most organizations correctly calculate that their own IT team would do it worse or more expensively. Medieval retainers were simpler to maintain than modern distributed systems.
  • The network itself remains resilient: The original ARPANET-inspired design (distributed nodes, packet switching, dynamic routing) still makes the internet backbone hard to take down as a whole. The vulnerability is at the application and data layer where consolidation has occurred for efficiency reasons. This is more like princes outsourcing their armies to a powerful neighboring king who is usually reliable — until he isn’t — rather than purely frittering resources on silk.
  • Incentives point the same way for almost everyone: Individuals, small businesses, enterprises, and governments all face the same convenience and cost pressures. There is no large class of actors sitting on unused surplus that they are simply wasting on status; the market has optimized for the centralized model.

The Tragedy of the Commons, or Lack Thereof

In 1968, Garrett Hardin wrote an influential paper named “The Tragedy of the Commons”. It was published in Science and was kind of a big deal. The paper was about the problem of common resources that can be rationally over-used by individuals such that the resources are destroyed – making everyone worse off. The general idea is a great insight and we can see examples everywhere. People being loud in public spaces, odiferous foods microwaved in the breakroom, spoiled food that remains in the refrigerator. These are relatively innocuous. But more substantial parallels include dumping waste into common water sources, overfishing/hunting, or over-harvesting trees or scavenging in common forests.

The Original Problem

Harden was specifically concerned with human overpopulation. He wrote in the same vein as Paul Ehrlich, who published “The Population Bomb” in the same year. Harden explains that the universe, and earth specifically, only has so much matter and carrying capacity for humans. He left the limiting constraint open. Maybe there would be inadequate clean air, water, nutritious food, etc. The specific inadequacy doesn’t matter, they are all due to the finiteness of our world.

From Hardin’s perspective, there was no natural prophylactic that would prevent us from bumping into the natural and horrifying constraint that inadequate resources would impose. He thought that people would continue to reproduce at greater than replacement rates and death would ensue. He also astutely pointed out that if good people agree to limit their number of offspring, then we will be left with only bad people reproducing. They’d place everyone at risk with their irresponsible, though entirely rational, folly. He concludes that the only hope for humanity is a mutual consent to a coercive entity that would prevent this commons problem of over-reproduction.

The Typical Response and its Shortcoming

The most popular argument against Hardin comes from Julian Simon, who argued that humans are the source of innovation and ingenuity and that more humans implies more innovation. Against Paul Ehrlich, Simon famously bet that commodity prices would fall over the course of the 1980s, asserting that human ingenuity would increase abundance.

Putting the wager aside, Simon’s idea that humans figure out ways to make resources more accessible is entirely correct – except for when it isn’t. The Malthusian booms and busts in population and persistent subsistent income levels did occur historically. But it’s been a long time since then. For a few hundred years we’ve had increasing standards of living *and* an increasing population. There are exceptions. There’s been starvation in Venezuela, Cuba, Ethiopia, China, North Korea, and Ukraine. These countries were plenty populous with plenty of human minds to tackle the challenges of scarcity. More people = more abundance isn’t exactly what Julian Simon said, but it’s how a lot of people answer Hardin and Ehrlich’s predictions.

The Better Responses

Continue reading →

Place-Based Subsidies Aren’t Great Job Creators

That turned out to be the commonality among the four papers I discussed at the Association for Public Policy Analysis and Management last weekend:

In “Subsidizing Data Centers”, Vijay Prakash found that US states subsidizing data centers saw no significant difference in unemployment (or electric prices) compared to those that didn’t.

2. In “Spillover Effects of Million Dollar Projects on Wage Distribution and Skill Demand“, Alaa Abdelfattah (with Layla O’Kane) found that big new business projects (mean investment $333 million, mean subsidy $130 million) led to no increase in total job postings in the counties that ‘won’ the project relative to counties that were reportedly the ‘runner-up’.

3. Of course, if you spend enough money, it is possible to bring jobs to an area. In “Where the CHIPS Fall: Local Labor Market Impacts of Semiconductor Mega-Investments in Maricopa County, Arizona“, Pinghui Wu (with Annie Liu) found that the billions spent on subsidies did bring jobs to Arizona- but at a cost of $136,000 to $190,000 per job-year.

4. Will the jobs remain once the subsidies are gone? They mostly didn’t in Puerto Rico. In “Corporate Tax Incentives Retraction: Evidence from Puerto Rico”, Dayanara M. Diaz Vargas found that the end of Section 936 tax credits in 2006 led to a 28% decline in manufacturing employment.

The results reminded me of subsidies for sports stadiums, which always promise to bring jobs and economic activity but rarely deliver:

With Inflation Staying High, Consider I-Bonds

The latest CPI-U data suggests inflation was around 4 percent in the past year (I say “around” because due to the late 2025 government shutdown, we have no October 2025 baseline data to calculate the rate). The persistently high inflation — even using the core CPI, it is still close to 3 percent — and currently high interest has made some investors consider the safer, more guaranteed returns of good old bonds.

One type of bond you may want to consider: Series I Bonds. These bonds issued by the federal government pay a rate that is set for 6 months, and the rate is based on the most recent 6 months of inflation as measured by the CPI-U (plus a fixed rate, more on that in a moment). These bonds are currently paying 5.51 percent, since the most 6 months of CPI-U inflation was 2 percent, which you essentially double to get an annual rate, and then a fixed rate (currently 1.4 percent) is added to that inflation rate. When you buy the bond, the fixed portion of the rate is fixed for the life of the bond (30 years). That 5.51 percent is currently higher than the 10-year Treasury bond, and even slightly better than the 30-year bond! But the rate is only guaranteed for 6 months, after which it will change.

The biggest reason to buy these now is not the headline rate but the fixed rate of 1.4 percent. That’s the best fixed rate they have offered since 2006-2007! I purchased some of these bonds back in 2022, and I still think it was a good choice: they were paying over 7 percent at the time, which increased to 9.62 percent the following 6 months. Not a bad return in a year when the stock market was unstable and actually fell almost 20 percent that full year. But when I purchased the I-Bonds in 2022, there was no fixed rate attached. That means the 2022 bonds I am still holding are currently just 4 percent, rather than the headline 5.51 percent.

Even if you believe that CPI-U inflation will eventually get back down to 2 percent, and stay there into the future, I-Bonds purchased now will pay almost 3.5 percent for the life of the bond — not a stellar return, but not bad for a guaranteed return. Of course, you could always lock in almost 5 percent for 10 years or over 5 percent for 30 years with ordinary Treasury Bonds. Those aren’t bad ideas other. But if you think inflation will remain elevated, or especially if you think it will ramp up again, putting some of your cash in I-Bonds might make sense.

As a historical point of reference, the best time to buy these bonds would have been in the late 1990s, when they were first issued. At the time they paid a fixed rate of over 3 percent! That means today those bonds are paying 7.5 percent and had been paying as high as 13 percent in 2022 at the peak of CPI-U inflation. Not bad for a guaranteed return! The cumulative return on a $10,000 investment in 1998 would be about 5x, today worth over $50,000. That’s only about half the return of the S&P 500 — but with much less volatility. Those high fixed rates are unlikely to return soon, but the 1.4 percent fixed rate is not too shabby.

Important final thoughts: don’t take this as professional investment advice, just as an idea to research more on your own and with your financial advisor. You can only put $10,000 per year into Series I Bonds, so no need to think about whether you should move all of your money into I Bonds — just think about the margin dollar you are investing. And if you sell these bonds within 5 years, you will lose a small amount of interest (3 months’ worth).

Potential Effects on Nvidia of Jensen Huang’s Affair with Alleged Chinese Spy

Image Source

You couldn’t make this up. The CEO of the second most valuable company on earth, at the very center of the AI technology which is driving, well, everything, including the U.S./China rivalry – – Jensen Huang himself – – over the weekend acknowledged over the weekend in an internal Nvidia memo that he had had an extramarital affair, and the company announced an investigation. The issue is not his personal infidelity, but the fact that the other woman in the case is almost certainly one Alice Huang (a.k.a. Huang Le) who is suspected by U.S. intelligence (per the NY Times) to be a Chinese spy.

There seems no question about the affair. There are lots of public photographs indicating an intimate relationship, and Huang outright admitted it, although he refrained from naming names. But who is Alice Huang? That turns out to be a very, very difficult question to answer.

She is reportedly a Chinese citizen, and was presumably born and raised and schooled there. I could find no solid information on her background. I asked Claude, and got this non-answer:

Birthplace and upbringing: I found no source giving either. AFP calls public details about her sparse. france24

Education: Officechai says there is no verified public record of where she studied or what degrees she holds. A fund-database profile lists jobs but, as far as the reporting says, no schools, and AFP couldn’t verify that profile or who wrote it. officechaifrance24

Some sources claim that she worked as a TV reporter in China, but other news organizations have checked and found those claims to be baseless. So…you have this person from China, coming seemingly out of nowhere, who rather suddenly as head of as her own firm Huang Le Ltd (registered in the British Virgin Islands) became owner of a spinoff (Megaspeed) of a Chinese company, which in turn rather suddenly becomes one of the biggest Asian importers of those oh-so-special Nvidia chips. There seems to be no ready accounting for how her firm was financed to buy Megaspeed, and or how such a tiny new firm could buy $4.6 billion (!!) in chips from Nvidia. Thus, some invisible hand deftly placed this hot youngish woman from China in a position where she would almost certainly come in personal contact with Jensen Huang.

She apparently palled around with Jensen in the years 2024-2025, but now has disappeared from her management roles and from public view. She seems to have been well-enough advised to avoid making outright illegal business moves (thus evading criminal prosecution in Singapore), but all this caught the attention of U.S. authorities as early as the late Biden administration, leading them to believe she was a tool of Chinese state intelligence – at least, that is what various news outlets have reported. It’s impossible to know what did or did not transpire between Huang and Huang regarding chip technology or policies, whatever else they talked about. It is a positive that Jensen has publicly acknowledged this affair, since that removes the blackmail lever which is often the point of such “honey pot” entrapments.

What effect might this all have on Nvidia? Well, first, its stock price was down sharply on Monday, erasing some $200 billion in shareholder value, when the rest of the chip stocks were recovering smartly from the fears from the midterms that the Democrats would shut down data center construction.

A lengthy, messy investigation might compromise Jensen Huang’s iconic role at Nvidia, leading potentially to his departure. The company would forge ahead without him, but his loss would be a blow. Even if he stays, his public image of a loyal, disciplined, trustworthy man has been badly tarnished.  I suspect a more focused fallout will be to muzzle him as a spokesman for selling more of his AI-critical (and military-enabling) chips to China. He has been pushing for chip sales for a long time, and now it will be tougher to take him seriously as someone speaking in America’s interest.