Place-Based Subsidies Aren’t Great Job Creators

That turned out to be the commonality among the four papers I discussed at the Association for Public Policy Analysis and Management last weekend:

In “Subsidizing Data Centers”, Vijay Prakash found that US states subsidizing data centers saw no significant difference in unemployment (or electric prices) compared to those that didn’t.

2. In “Spillover Effects of Million Dollar Projects on Wage Distribution and Skill Demand“, Alaa Abdelfattah (with Layla O’Kane) found that big new business projects (mean investment $333 million, mean subsidy $130 million) led to no increase in total job postings in the counties that ‘won’ the project relative to counties that were reportedly the ‘runner-up’.

3. Of course, if you spend enough money, it is possible to bring jobs to an area. In “Where the CHIPS Fall: Local Labor Market Impacts of Semiconductor Mega-Investments in Maricopa County, Arizona“, Pinghui Wu (with Annie Liu) found that the billions spent on subsidies did bring jobs to Arizona- but at a cost of $136,000 to $190,000 per job-year.

4. Will the jobs remain once the subsidies are gone? They mostly didn’t in Puerto Rico. In “Corporate Tax Incentives Retraction: Evidence from Puerto Rico”, Dayanara M. Diaz Vargas found that the end of Section 936 tax credits in 2006 led to a 28% decline in manufacturing employment.

The results reminded me of subsidies for sports stadiums, which always promise to bring jobs and economic activity but rarely deliver:

Fiscal Health & Divided Government

For the past two years, we’ve had a unified government in which the Republican party has populated the White House and had majorities in both chambers of congress. Once the new legislators are in office we’ll have a divided government. That means that the political party controling the White House won’t also control the senate and house of representatives. In the spirit of saying something of substance, I want to know what the implications are for our fiscal picture.

One can measure fiscal health in many ways. Does a divided government bode well for shrinking the deficit? Rather than spit-ball about politics, I take the data since 1960 in one hand and a model in the other. See the end notes for model details.

Since 1960, the most popular form of government split has been a Democratic president and unified government, followed by Republican presidents and a divided government. Democrats have controlled at least one chamber of congress for 62% of the years. Do these splits matter for federal outlays, receipts, and the deficit? Since a unified democratic government was most common, I use that as the baseline fiscal case and compare the cases to it.

Below are the average impacts of government-party types on federal spending, revenues, and the deficit. The blanks are insignificant differences. On average, the only party split that results in less spending is a Democrat president with divided government. Those and unified Republican governments raise more revenue and reduce the budget deficit from its trend (there was a small decline in in discretionary spending at the start of Trump’s 2nd term with a unified government).  The bad news for deficit hawks is that Republican presidents with a divided government – the type that we’ll have for the next two years – perform poorly. On average, they reduce government revenue and increase the deficit. Again, all of this is ‘on average’.

Continue reading →

By the Numbers: Florida’s Property Tax Amendment (2026)

Voters this November will face a proposed amendment to the Florida state constitution on property tax reform. Currently, Florida has what’s called a ‘homestead’ exemption of $50,000. If a residential property is your primary residence, then your home’s assessed value is $50k less before taxes are calculated. There is no exemption for rental property or 2nd homes or vacation homes. The proposed amendment increases the exemption to $250k by 2028 and then indexes it to inflation.

First, let’s get an idea of the magnitudes. The median home in Florida is priced at about $400k and the average property tax rate is around 0.8%. Below compares the current consolidated tax bill against that of the proposed amendment. Given current home prices and local tax rates, the new exemption would have a huge impact on municipal governments who get the bulk of their revenue from property tax. In fact, there is no Florida state property tax, so the proposed amendment would adopt a new rule for municipalities and not the state government.

What Motivates the Amendment?

The current homestead exemption of $50k was established in 2008. A subsequent amendment in 2024 allowed half of that to be indexed to CPI-U. The average home price in Florida has risen 114% since 2008 and 84% since 2020. That’s a lot faster than inflation, but the tax burden is partially offset by a maximum of 3% annual increase in assessed value. Regardless, many individuals face a larger tax bill over time even independent of whether their income or use of public services has changed. Plenty people are feeling the squeeze.

What’s the Purpose of the Homestead Exemption?

The exemption is available for primary residences only. That means that rentals and vacation homes do not qualify. It’s important to keep in mind that, given some total revenue, every tax break for one group or activity implies a higher tax rate for others. So, clearly, the effect is to tax residents less and tax seasonal residents and visitors more. Florida doesn’t have an income tax, but it does have a sales tax, gasoline tax, and others that are disproportionately borne by non-residents. Given that higher income individuals tend to have higher home values, the homestead exemption is a way to lower the tax burden of lower income households. Obviously, the lowest income individuals are renters, but so are non-residents who Florida prefers to tax.

The Economics

Homeowners

The exemption is enjoyed by all primary residences, but helps low income owners the most. And, given a stable amount of municipal tax revenue, a higher homestead exemption requires that municipalities replace that revenue. This might take the form of higher local fees and taxes, making life harder for lower income people to, say, own a car or make purchase if taxes on those activities rise. Revenue stability might also be helped by higher property tax rates. The higher the property value is above $250k, the greater the average tax burden that is borne. So, someone with a very high property value may find themselves with an even higher property tax bill after municipalities adjust to the proposed statewide rule. In this sense, the new amendment would be a step in the direction of tax progressivity (a higher proportion taxed from those with higher income/wealth).

Indexing

Normally, I am in favor of indexing nominal values to CPI. In this case, we need to think about what the goal is. Let’s assume that the goals is to provide relief to lower income homeowners specifically and all primary residence homeowners generally. Does indexing to the CPI help? It depends!

Continue reading →

You can learn economics in the most unexpected places.

Economics is everywhere, but I find endless enjoyment in watching others learn about economics in unexpected places. In this case, it’s in the largest Dungeons and Dragons subreddit, where a particularly long-playing and supremely powerful group of adventurers get the bright idea to institute a tax…on magic. What could possibly go wrong?

Well, that is precisely the discussion that emerges. All the things that will and should go wrong if you decide to place a tax on what is essentially the wellspring of all technology and welfare in their world. All healthcare, production, sanitation, agriculture, public safety, etc etc. It all comes back to magic. And these hearty and hale adventurers think it would nice to rake in a few extra million gold pieces by placing, and presumably enforcing, a tax on it.

What’s fascinating is to walk through the comments and watch the crowd collectively puzzle out all the ways this is going to backfire, only to then march through ways the world is going to collectively respond and eventually rebel. There’s a reason why most tax discussions eventually become, at the very least, targeted and, at their very best, highly nuanced. Because it is no small decision how a society should best leverage taxation as a means to solve a problem. Do we want to tax the rich? Ok, what’s the line at rich? Do we want to eliminate regressive taxes targeting the poor? Ok, but is this only a tax or is it doing something else as well?

In this world of magic and mayhem, we see our heroic players stumble into literally the worst possible thing you could ever tax: the entire body of technology. Not labor, not capital, not income, not capital gains…no, they target the single most important input into all of economic growth and human welfare. From a pedagogical point of view, this is <chef kisses fingers> perfection. Absolutely no notes. I’m not kidding when I say that, if I was still teaching Principles of Economics, I would build a class discussion around this exact thread.

And special shout out the commenter to worked through the economic, political, and ecumenical consequences in real time:

It’s economics all the way down, apparently even into the depths of The Nine Hells.